She asked me a question I still can't answer


I sat across from a woman last week who has heard a story like mine before. Not from hundreds of people. From a couple.

She was kind. She was sharp. She'd been through something similar herself.

She asked good questions. I answered most of them fine.

Then she asked one I didn't see coming.

Why did you let the money move into his name. Why did you let the house go into his name only. You're smart. You're capable. Why would you let that happen.

I didn't have a good answer.

I sat there, a grown woman, years out from that marriage, and felt the old feeling again. The one where you can't explain yourself and the not-explaining feels like proof you did something wrong.

I understand the shape of how you lose your money, in a general way. Not all at once. Not with a signature you'd refuse to sign. He'd ask me to move something "just for now," or "just to make it simpler." Each ask small enough that saying no felt petty.

One yes at a time, until I looked up and none of it was mine anymore.

But knowing the shape of how it happens and having a good answer for why it happened to me are two different things. I still don't have the second one.

That's the part nobody tells you about healing. It's not a finish line. It's not a place where every hard question has a ready response. Sometimes someone you trust asks you something fair, and the old shame shows up before the new understanding does.

I don't fully know why. And maybe that's the honest answer — that I didn't question it enough at the time. Not questioning it is what let it happen, one small yes after another, until I looked up and none of it was mine.

By the time we finished, I'd been sitting with all of it for five hours. Jaycee had been home alone the whole time, plus the drive.

On the way back I found myself worrying about her the way you worry about someone small and defenseless who can't call you to say she's fine. I pictured her waiting by the door, wondering where I'd gone.

When I walked in, she was exactly herself. Thrilled. Wiggling. Not one ounce of the story I'd built up in the car — no hurt feelings, no need for me to explain where I'd been or why it took so long. Just happy I was home.

She didn't need a good answer from me either. She just needed me to walk back through the door.

Maybe that's the whole lesson from a day full of hard questions. Some of the people who love you most aren't waiting on your explanation. They're just waiting on you.

Before You Go
That question — "why didn't I have a good answer" — might be one you've asked yourself too, about something in your own life.
​
Where do you land? Pick one:
​
Just click the one that's true for you. No reply needed.

Jane and Jaycee, of course.

The Jane & Jaycee Project

A weekly letter for woman starting over.

Read more from The Jane & Jaycee Project

Hello, I have spent most of my life thinking of myself as a smart, capable woman. So for a long time, one sentence has followed me around. I should have known better. This week I read an article by a writer I subscribe to, Shadows of Control, called “I Chose Him. But I Didn’t Choose the Way He Treated Me.” It put a different question beside that sentence. Not “why didn’t I know?” but “what did I actually know at the time, and what was hidden from me?” She also offers a companion guide to her...

Hello, I’m going to try something different for the next few weeks, and I want to tell you plainly what it is. I’m going to look, honestly, at why I stayed. Why I went along with things I should have questioned. Why I agreed to ideas about money that look ridiculous to me now. This is not a light look back. I’m not doing it to make a good story. I’m doing it because I want to know. And I don’t know yet what I’ll find. Here is where I’m starting. Early in my relationship with Eddie, I left my...

Yesterday was three years since I left. I was already up, dressed, having my coffee, when I decided. Twenty minutes later I was out the door with everything I was taking. I planned it all in silence, because leaving had never been something I was allowed to try. What I didn't have was any idea where I was going. By then I had been disappearing for a long time. I had been made to cut off my own family. There was no one I could call. And even if I could have, I wasn't sure my friends or my...